1590 ‘Pasquil’ sig. B2v I warrant you the cunning Pap-maker knewe what he did, when he made choyse of no other spoone than a hatchet for such a mouth.
1838 (Electronic text) Feb. I had no idea you had such a propensity to dry nursing, or I should have before promoted you as pap and panada maker in general.
2002 (Nexis) 19 Apr. (headline) Pap maker and ‘roaring’ scarecrow among inventions.