If someone catches you off guard, they surprise you by doing something you do not expect. If something catches you off guard, it surprises you by happening when you are not expecting it.
Charm the audience and catch them off guard.
The invitation had caught me off guard.
See full dictionary entry for guard
catch someone off guard
to completely surprise someone
There was a bright flash, followed a few moments later by a thunderous roar thatcaught us all off guard.